Apple Cider Inspecting Topics
  You are Here: Home > Inspecting Topics > Recommended Practices > Guide to Inspectors
  


Recommended Practices to Improve Cider Safety

(Guide to Inspectors of Manufacturers of Miscellaneous Food Products -- Volume 1)

a. Vinegar, Cider, Apple Juice Establishment Inspection
b. Raw Materials
c. Manufacturing Process
d. Sample Collecting
e. Reporting Form


GUIDE TO INSPECTIONS OF MANUFACTURERS OF MISCELLANEOUS FOOD PRODUCTS - VOLUME 1 Note: This document is reference material for investigators and other FDA personnel. The document does not bind FDA, and does no confer any rights, privileges, benefits, or immunities for or on any person(s).

This guide is divided into multiple sections. Each section provides specific instructions and information applicable to the individual product or products covered. Prior to conducting any inspection involving any food product manufacturer, review the FD&C Act Chapter IV, Food, 21 CFR 110, GMP's on Food, and the general inspectional instructions in IOM Chapter


SECTION 8: VINEGAR, CIDER, APPLE JUICE
ESTABLISHMENT INSPECTION

In addition to information and instructions provided in IOM Subchapter 530, review Compliance Policy Guide 7109.22 for guidance as to the identity and labeling of various kinds of vinegars. Additionally, reconstituted apple juice, reconstituted cider, and apple juice concentrate are prime candidates for intentional economic adulteration. See Section 10: Orange/Other Juice in this chapter for guidance with respect to juice adulteration. Follow the guidance in that section with respect to possible adulterants in the plant and sample collection for economic adulteration.

Direct special attention to the following areas when inspecting these types of food establishments: Unpasteurized apple cider has been associated with outbreaks of food illness caused by pathogenic E. Coli 0157:H7. The apples used to make the cider were believed to have become contaminated with cow manure either from grazing cows in the apple orchard or from the use of cow manure as a fertilizer. Contamination of the apple cider with E. Coli resulted from improperly cleaning of the apples prior to pressing the juice and/or cross contamination from the raw apples to the finished apple cider. Studies on the survival of E. Coli 0157:H7 in unpasteurized apple cider with a pH between 3.6 and 4.0 have shown the organism to be acid tolerant. The use of sodium benzoate 0.1% was shown to reduce the survival rate and have a preservative effect.

back to the top


Raw Materials
Determine the firm's specifications for incoming apples. If "drops" are used (apples that have fallen from the tree) what precautions are taken to prevent microbiological contamination of finished product? Inspect incoming apples for evidence of rot and worms. Refer to USDA Publication No. 168, "Market Diseases of Fruit and Vegetables, Apples, Pears, Quinces". Characteristics of bruised vs rotten apples are contrasted as follows:

1.Bruised apples:
a) skin and tissue brown, dry, and spongy;
b) no disagreeable odor or taste;
c) slight tissue penetration.

2.Rotten apples:
a) external rot: skin and tissue substantially browned, skin sometimes in concentric circles;
b) soft rot: slight skin discoloration; none in freshly cut tissue; tissue is soft and pulpy;
c) off odor and taste;
d) internal rot: tissue penetrated in a cone toward the core.

Conduct field examination as follows:

1. Collect 100 apples at random from stock going directly to the chopper after sorting.
2. Examine apples for external rot and segregate by size of rot spots.
3. Cut each apple and examine for internal rot and worm damage.
4. If 5% or more unfit apples are found, repeat the examinations over a sufficient period to establish a pattern.
5. If stock going into chopper consist of 5% or more unfit apples, collect and examine similar samples at random from stock in storage.
6. If peels and cores are used, select a representative sample and weigh. Segregate wormy cores.
Trim cores with rot spots. Weigh reject material and report it as percent of the weighed sample.

back to the top


Manufacturing Process
If the firm is manufacturing pasteurized apple juice or pasteurized apple cider, evaluate the firm's pasteurization method and equipment. Pasteurization should be equivalent to heating the product for 30 minutes at 155F or 15 seconds at 180F. You may wish to consult with your regional milk specialist or district LACF expert before inspecting a pasteurized juice product.

Follow procedures outlined in Section 7, under Dressings, in evaluating the firm's cleaning procedures for equipment and CIP system.

Determine if there are conditions or practices that could result in contamination of the finished product from handling or processing the raw, unwashed apples, i.e., common equipment, switching jobs by employees, cross connections between raw and pasteurized product lines, etc. If the firm is manufacturing unpasteurized apple cider, determine what controls are used and what test are conducted to assure the finished product is not contaminated. If the firm is adding a preservative, review formulation and determine what preservative is being used and at what strength. Check against the Food Additive Status List in the IOM.

If unpasteurized apple cider is being produced, collect samples of both the finished product and the raw apples and submit to the servicing laboratory for microbiological analysis.

Check for the substitution of colored acetic acid or distilled vinegar for apple cider vinegar or wine vinegar when inspecting vinegar manufacturers.

Vinegar generators may become infested with vinegar eels unless steam cleaned frequently. Vinegar eels in bulk vinegar storage tanks prior to filtration are not considered an insanitary condition. However, the presence of vinegar eels in finished bottled vinegar would render the product adulterated. Determine what test are conducted for acidity in the vinegar. The acetic acid concentration should be 4% or higher.

back to the top


SAMPLE COLLECTION
Investigational
Microbiological
If inspectional conditions warrant, collect in-line samples for microbiological examination using aseptic techniques. Refrigerate and ship to the servicing laboratory as soon as possible after collection. In-line subs should be approximately 4 oz. of material per sub. Collect at least 30 units of finished product as part of your in-line sample.

Filth (collect separate from microbiological sample)
When wormy or rotten whole and cut apples or peels and cores are used and plant conditions are objectionable, collect exhibits and preserve in saturated borax solution containing 0.1% ascorbic acid.

1. Take close-up color photographs of wormy or rotten whole and cut apples, drosophila infestation, and other objectionable conditions.
2. Collect two quart sub samples of pomace, unclarified and unfiltered juice, and residue from filter. Do not sample filtered juice if it appears that contamination is being removed by filter. Preserve pomace and juice with 2 cc of formalin per 100 grams of material.

Official
Juice or Cider
Microbiological
- collect at least 30 retail units from each identifiable lot.

Filth - take sufficient sub samples to total 3 gallons, but not less than 6 individual containers.

Vinegar
Bottles - take sufficient sub samples to total 2 gallons.
Barrels - sample 1 gallon from each of 5 barrels.
Caution: do not use rubber tubing and do not place vinegar in metal top jars. Rinse jars with vinegar before filling.

back to the top


REPORTING
Report the number and percent wormy apples, and then the total number and percent wormy and/or rotten apples, counting each apple only once. Report the results of examination to the firm on the FDA-483 as follows:

Source of Sample: _______________
Number of apples examined: ___________________

Wormy Apples (include wormy apples with rot spots).
Apples with rot spots: Class 1 - 1/4 to 1/2 in. dia. ________ (#)                   ________ (%)
                                 Class 2 - 1/2 to 1 in. dia.   ________ (#)                   ________ (%)
                                 Class 3 - 1 to 1/2 in. dia.   ________ (#)                   ________ (%)
                                 Class 4 - over 1/2 apple.    ________ (#)                   ________ (%)

Total Total number with rot spots and/or worm (count only once) ________ (#)    ________ (%)

back to the top


Back to Home || Wisconsin FIRST || Contact Us

University of Wisconsin - Madison
Copyright © 2001-2008, Department of Food Science,
University of Wisconsin-Madison.